Few questions from safari participants make me cringe as much as the one about using a Teleconverter with their consumer or prosumer lenses. Both Nikon and Canon have worked hard on excellent Teleconverters for their high-end pro Telephoto lenses, but for some good reasons have orphaned their other lenses in that regard. Solutions were all ugly, involving a loss of Auto-Focus and often physical modifications to lenses. But now all that has changed with the introduction of the …
Before I sing some of the praises of the new Kenko DGX converters I want to state a couple massive caveats up front. First and foremost, consumer and prosumer lenses aren’t built with the ultra-sharp optics required to get tack sharp images with a Teleconverter. So there is going to be some loss of sharpness with any Teleconverter for those lenses. But in many cases the tradeoff may be worth it if it is the only cost effective way you can reach the focal length you need.
And second, even though the new Kenko TCs amazingly support AutoFocus (at least in the configurations I tested it) like any Teleconverter it will reduce the available light (by 1 stop for a 1.4x) so you’re not going to get blazingly fast AF by the time you take a relatively slow consumer lens and drop another stop of light. Any teleconverter, especially on a less expensive lens, is not a substitute for a larger, longer, and more expensive dedicated lens--but it's certainly a lot less expensive and can be a lot more convenient.
All that said, the and are pretty impressive. The very first welcome surprise is that it mated perfectly with the Nikon and Sigma lenses I tried without any of the hacking and filing that is needed to get the Nikon Teleconverters to mount to them. It went on smoothly and appeared to lock nicely. Like other Kenko products I wouldn’t compare the build quality to a similar Nikon product. It is less than half the price and some of that cost savings is from a slightly less elegant and robust build. But it was solid and seems like it will hold up well.
This image shows a park sign at f/8 with the Nikon 24-120 (VR version) and the new Kenko 1.4TC. The 24-120 is an “okay” lens to start with and with the Teleconverter you can certainly see that the letters on the sign are not razor sharp, but they are remarkably good considering that we just increased our effective focal length from 120 to 170 for only $200. Note that the image is at f/8 so that the planes in the background are not razor sharp partially because of focus, independent of the sharpness of the lens and converter.
Below is a landscape scene to give you a sense of the images which are possible with a standard consumer lens and the Teleconverter.
The newest version of the Teleconverters, the and also have one other nice feature. It correctly reports the effective f-Stop of the combination of the lens and teleconverter—the older versions wouldn’t take into account the light reduction from the Teleconverter.
Another caveat about this type of teleconverter solution is I’d really hesitate to push it past 1.4x. More than that and the light loss and optical issues are going to pile up. With the 1.4x version I was very pleased that (as you can see above) there is virtually no light falloff in the corners, even on the full frame Nikon D700.
Now that I’ve taken the TC out for a spin with a standard consumer lens I’ll be experimenting using on my bear safaris with some of my Pro lenses to see if it makes sense as a less expensive alternative to the Nikon AF-S Teleconverters. It correctly mounts on my Pro AF-S lenses and does a good job of Auto-focusing, but next will come a test of image quality.